ER70S-2 vs ER70S-3: Which Solid Welding Wire Should You Choose?

Compare ER70S-2 and ER70S-3 welding wire by chemical composition, deoxidizing elements, applications, and selection considerations.

2292

ER70S-2 vs ER70S-3: What Is the Main Difference?

The main difference between ER70S-2 and ER70S-3 is their deoxidizing system.
  • ER70S-2 contains additional titanium, zirconium, and aluminum, along with manganese and silicon.
  • ER70S-3 mainly relies on manganese and silicon for deoxidation.
Both are solid carbon steel welding wires classified under AWS A5.18. However, their different chemical compositions make them suitable for different welding conditions.
Comparison
ER70S-2
ER70S-3
Main deoxidizers
Mn, Si, Ti, Zr, Al
Mn, Si
Carbon content
≤ 0.07%
0.06–0.15%
Manganese
0.90–1.40%
0.90–1.40%
Silicon
0.40–0.70%
0.45–0.75%
Typical use
Applications requiring additional deoxidizing elements
General carbon steel fabrication
Key consideration
Additional Ti, Zr, and Al
Conventional Mn-Si deoxidizing system

1. How Does Chemical Composition Affect Welding Performance?

The additional deoxidizing elements are the most noticeable difference between these two wires.
ER70S-2 contains titanium, zirconium, and aluminum in addition to manganese and silicon. These elements contribute to deoxidation during welding and help control the effects of oxygen in the weld metal.
ER70S-3 uses a conventional manganese-silicon deoxidizing system. Its composition is suitable for many routine carbon steel welding applications where the specified material and welding procedure allow its use.
This difference does not mean ER70S-2 can be used on heavily contaminated steel without preparation. Oil, rust, paint, moisture, and other contaminants should still be removed as required by the welding procedure.

2. When Should You Choose ER70S-2?

Choose ER70S-2 when the application specifically calls for its chemical composition or additional deoxidizing elements.
Typical considerations include:
  • Welding applications where ER70S-2 is specified by the welding procedure.
  • Pipe, tubing, and general carbon steel fabrication where the required filler metal matches this classification.
  • Welding conditions where its Ti-Zr-Al deoxidizing system is a relevant selection factor.
ER70S-2 is available in different product forms and sizes depending on the manufacturer. Confirm whether you need MIG wire or TIG filler rod before ordering.

3. When Is ER70S-3 a Suitable Choice?

ER70S-3 is commonly selected for general-purpose carbon steel welding.
Typical applications include:
  • General steel fabrication.
  • Sheet and plate welding.
  • Machinery and equipment manufacturing.
  • Metal structures and fabrication components.
It can be considered when the base material, welding process, shielding gas, and required mechanical properties are compatible with the specified welding procedure.

4. Can ER70S-2 Replace ER70S-3?

Not automatically.
Although both wires have an AWS classification strength level of 70 ksi and share similar manganese content, their carbon content and deoxidizing elements are different.
Before substituting one for the other, check:
  • The base metal and its chemical composition.
  • The applicable welding procedure and filler metal requirements.
  • Required mechanical properties and service conditions.
  • Welding process and shielding gas.
  • Project specifications and applicable codes.
For code-controlled or critical applications, any substitution should be reviewed and approved by the responsible welding engineer.

5. Which Welding Wire Should You Choose?

Use this quick guide:
Your requirement
Wire to consider
Additional Ti, Zr, and Al deoxidizing elements are required
ER70S-2
General carbon steel fabrication
ER70S-3
A project specification explicitly requires ER70S-2
ER70S-2
A project specification explicitly requires ER70S-3
ER70S-3
The correct choice depends on the base material, welding procedure, and application requirements—not simply on which wire has more deoxidizing elements.

Need ER70S-2 Welding Wire?

GD WELD supplies specialty welding consumables for industrial applications.
If you are looking for ER70S-2 welding wire, contact us with your required diameter, product form, quantity, and application. Our team can help you check the appropriate specification.
Request a Quote: Send us your welding consumable requirements for further information.

Read next

More from the journal

Keep readers moving through related announcements, stories, and field notes.